Common use of No Action Alternative Clause in Contracts

No Action Alternative. Under the No Action Alternative, the proposed SHA would not be implemented and the USFWS would not issue Permits to the Applicants. Under this alternative, the Applicants would continue to conduct their forest management activities in accordance with applicable Forest Practices Rules in Oregon and Washington (Sections 2.1.1 and 2.1.2 below), and would avoid take of the northern spotted owl by not harvesting the 4,697 acres of suitable owl that is currently restricted from harvest under Washington Forest Practices Rules. The Applicants would implement an approximate 45-year timber-harvest rotation. When forest stands, or appropriately sized patches of forest, reach 45 years of age, they would be harvested for regeneration. SDS and BLC would conduct pre-commercial thinning, and commercial thinning would be conducted where economically practicable as part of their forest management plan, but not to accelerate spotted owl habitat growth under the No Action Alternative. The following list briefly describes the forest management activities associated with the No Action Alternative. Not all of the conservation activities that are associated with standard Washington Forest Practices Rules (WAC Title 222) are identified below, however, any that are not included would apply equally to both alternatives. General forest management activities on commercial forests in Washington and Oregon:  plant and monitor until “free to grow”; controlling competing vegetation as needed;  pre-commercial thinning at 10-12 years old where conditions warrant it;  commercial thin where economically practical, but not to accelerate Young Forest Marginal (YFM) habitat;  monitor stand health and damage, and salvage opportunistically to recover value;  conduct regeneration harvest at an average age of 45 years; and  construct and maintain roads for forest management access. Wildlife Reserve Tree Management (WAC 222-30-020):  For each acre harvested in Eastern Washington, leave 2 wildlife reserve trees(>10 feet tall and >10 inches DBH), 2 green recruitment trees(>10 feet tall and >12 inches DBH), and 2 down logs(> 20 feet long and >12 inches diameter at small end). Northern spotted owl habitat conservation (WAC ▇▇▇-▇▇-▇▇, and ORS 527.610):  Retain 2,605 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat within 1.8 mile radius circles of owl site centers associated with SOSEAs. There are 18 of these circles that intersect with the applicants lands and a total of 4,697 acres of their lands have been identified as or are assumed to be part of this retention requirement in the White Salmon (14 circles and 3,694 acres) and Columbia Gorge (4 circles and 1,003 acres) SOSEAs;  Retention acres identified above are to include all suitable spotted owl habitat within 0.7 mile radius circles of owl site centers associated with SOSEAs. There are eight 0.7 mile radius circles that intersect with the applicants lands in the White Salmon SOSEA (see Table 2-2);  Outside of SOSEAS in Washington, during the nesting season, retain 70 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat surrounding a northern spotted owl site center. Currently there are no known spotted owl activity centers on the Applicants’ lands in Washington outside of the SOSEAs; and  In Oregon, retain 70 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat surrounding a northern spotted owl site center. Currently there are no known spotted owl activity centers on the Applicants’ lands in Oregon. SDS’ commercial forestland, defined as productive timberlands suitable for forestry, totals 46,244 acres in Washington and 12,141 acres in Oregon. BLC has 11,601 acres of commercial forestland in Washington (See SHA Figure 2-1 and SHA Table 3-1). The baseline includes all commercial forestland that the Applicants could harvest in Washington and Oregon under the current state Forest Practices Rules. Under Forest Practices Rules in Oregon, spotted owls are protected only where there is an active spotted owl nesting site or activity center occupied by a pair of adult owls capable of breeding. Protection of a 70-acre core area around the spotted owl nest site is required during the breeding season. Although, there are six spotted owl sites on USFS land in proximity to SDS lands, none of the 70-acre cores intersect SDS lands. Oregon Department of Forestry and USFWS records indicate that there are no known spotted owl nests on the Applicants land in Oregon. Applicants have covered lands outside of SOSEAs that consists of 47,523 acres (60% of which is in Washington and 40% in Oregon). Applicants’ commercial forestland outside of SOSEAs is 38,499 acres (SHA Table 3-1). Except for the restrictions on harvest of spotted owl habitat in the SOSEAs, the Applicants may harvest all suitable habitat on their ownership in Oregon and Washington under the No Action Alternative. Therefore, under the No Action Alternative, the Applicants’ current forest management regime in Oregon will focus timber harvest efforts on all stands that qualify as owl habitat with the goal of eliminating suitable spotted owl habitat within the next 10 years. The Applicants state that due to regulatory uncertainty they have substantially increased the rate of harvest as part of their strategy to harvest their most mature stands within the constraints of the Forest Practice Rules. This includes managing their lands on a 45-year rotation, harvesting surplus habitat (in excess of highest quality 2,605 acres) within 1.8 mile circles, and harvesting all spotted owl habitat outside of the 1.8 mile circles over the next 10 years. Applicants state they are strategically harvesting the highest quality habitat as early as possible. In addition to this management approach, the Applicants are not allowing non-habitat within spotted owl circles to grow into suitable owl habitat to avoid additional regulatory burdens. Currently, across all the covered lands, the Applicant owns 12,111 acres of dispersal habitat, 18,646 acres YFM habitat, and 18,478 acres Sub-Mature habitat (Table 2-1). Within the White Salmon SOSEA there are 6,168 acres of dispersal habitat, 6,685 acres YFM habitat, and 5,885 acres Sub-Mature habitat. Of these acres, only 3,694 acres are considered unavailable for harvest by State and Federal regulatory restrictions because the habitat occurs within 0.7 mile radius circles and/or is considered the highest quality habitat within 1.8 mile radius circles (Section 2.11 below). Dispersal habitat is not considered restricted from harvest. Thus, 15,044 acres in the White Salmon SOSEA are available for harvest in the next 10 years under the No Action Alternative. At the time of drafting the SHA and this EA, WDNR has not identified the restricted habitat in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA. In the absence of this data, Applicants are assuming that all of their 1,003 acres of habitat in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA is also restricted resulting in a total of 4,697 acres of habitat in the SOSEAs as restricted from harvest. All other habitat on the Applicants ownership is available for harvest under the No Action Alternative. Non Habitat (less than 39 yrs. old) 9,822 10,929 20,751 Dispersal (40-59 yrs. old) 6,168 5,943 12,111 Young Forest Marginal (typed by DNR & or 60-79 yrs.)1 6,685 11,961 18,646 Submature + (typed by DNR & or over 79 yrs. old)1,2 5,885 12,593 18,478 1 - habitat within owl circles typed by DNR; outside of owl circles age was used to type habitat 2 - includes Old Forest Habitat 3 - 741 acres Submature & 2,953 acres YFM 4 - 313 acres Submature & 690 acres YFM in Columbia Gorge SOSEA

Appears in 1 contract

Sources: Northern Spotted Owl Safe Harbor Agreement

No Action Alternative. Under the No Action Alternative, forested stands greater than 60 years old outside the proposed SHA would not be implemented and the USFWS would not issue Permits to 1.8-mile spotted owl home range radius on the Applicants. Under this alternative, the Applicants would continue ’ ownership in Washington will be targeted for harvest if they are likely to conduct their forest management activities in accordance with applicable Forest Practices Rules in Oregon and Washington (Sections 2.1.1 and 2.1.2 below), and would avoid take of the northern be spotted owl by not harvesting habitat as defined in the 4,697 acres of suitable owl that is currently restricted from harvest under Washington Forest Practices Rules. The Applicants would implement an approximate 45-year timber-harvest rotation. When forest standsIn Oregon, or appropriately sized patches of forest, reach stands greater than 45 years of ageage will also be targeted for harvest. Currently, they would be harvested for regeneration. SDS and BLC would conduct prethere are 18,646 acres of forest stands between 60-commercial thinning, and commercial thinning would be conducted where economically practicable as part 80 years of their forest management plan, but not to accelerate spotted owl habitat growth under the No Action Alternative. The following list briefly describes the forest management activities associated with the No Action Alternative. Not all of the conservation activities that are associated with standard Washington Forest Practices Rules (WAC Title 222) are identified below, however, any that are not included would apply equally to both alternatives. General forest management activities on commercial forests in Washington and Oregon:  plant and monitor until “free to grow”; controlling competing vegetation as needed;  pre-commercial thinning at 10-12 years old where conditions warrant it;  commercial thin where economically practical, but not to accelerate Young Forest Marginal age (YFM) habitat;  monitor stand health and damage, and salvage opportunistically to recover value;  conduct regeneration harvest at an average age of 45 years; and  construct and maintain roads for forest management access. Wildlife Reserve Tree Management (WAC 222-30-020):  For each acre harvested in Eastern Washington, leave 2 wildlife reserve trees(>10 feet tall and >10 inches DBH), 2 green recruitment trees(>10 feet tall and >12 inches DBH), and 2 down logs(> 20 feet long and >12 inches diameter at small end). Northern spotted owl habitat conservation (WAC ▇▇▇-▇▇-▇▇, and ORS 527.610):  Retain 2,605 18,478 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat within 1.8 mile radius circles forest stands greater than 80 years of owl site centers associated with SOSEAs. There are 18 of these circles that intersect with the applicants lands and a total of 4,697 acres of their lands have been identified as or are assumed to be part of this retention requirement in the White Salmon age (14 circles and 3,694 acresSub-Mature) and Columbia Gorge (4 circles and 1,003 acres) SOSEAs;  Retention acres identified above are to include all suitable spotted owl habitat within 0.7 mile radius circles of owl site centers associated with SOSEAs. There are eight 0.7 mile radius circles that intersect with the applicants lands in the White Salmon SOSEA (see Table 2-2);  Outside of SOSEAS in Washington, during the nesting season, retain 70 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat surrounding a northern spotted owl site center. Currently there are no known spotted owl activity centers on the Applicants’ lands in Washington outside of the SOSEAs; and  In Oregon, retain 70 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat surrounding a northern spotted owl site center. Currently there are no known spotted owl activity centers on the Applicants’ lands in Oregon. SDS’ commercial forestland, defined as productive timberlands suitable for forestry, totals 46,244 acres in Washington and 12,141 acres in Oregon. BLC has 11,601 acres of commercial forestland in Washington (See SHA Figure 2-1 and SHA Table 3-1). The baseline includes all commercial forestland that the Applicants could harvest in Washington and Oregon under the current state Forest Practices Rules. Under Forest Practices Rules in Oregon, spotted owls are protected only where there is an active spotted owl nesting site or activity center occupied by a pair of adult owls capable of breeding. Protection of a 70-acre core area around the spotted owl nest site is required during the breeding season. Although, there are six spotted owl sites on USFS land in proximity to SDS lands, none of the 70-acre cores intersect SDS lands. Oregon Department of Forestry and USFWS records indicate that there are no known spotted owl nests on the Applicants land in Oregon. Applicants have covered lands outside of SOSEAs that consists of 47,523 acres (60% of which is in Washington and 40% in Oregon). Applicants’ commercial forestland outside of SOSEAs is 38,499 acres (SHA Table 3-1). Except for the restrictions on harvest of spotted owl habitat in the SOSEAs, the Applicants may harvest all suitable habitat on their ownership in Oregon and Washington under the No Action Alternative. Therefore, under the No Action Alternative, the Applicants’ current forest management regime in Oregon will focus timber harvest efforts on all stands that qualify as owl habitat with the goal of eliminating suitable spotted owl habitat within the next 10 years. The Applicants state that due to regulatory uncertainty they have substantially increased the rate of harvest as part of their strategy to harvest their most mature stands within the constraints of the Forest Practice Rules. This includes managing their lands on a 45-year rotation, harvesting surplus habitat (in excess of highest quality 2,605 acres) within 1.8 mile circles, and harvesting all spotted owl habitat outside of the 1.8 mile circles over the next 10 years. Applicants state they are strategically harvesting the highest quality habitat as early as possible. In addition to this management approach, the Applicants are not allowing non-habitat within spotted owl circles to grow into suitable owl habitat to avoid additional regulatory burdens. Currently, across all the covered lands, the Applicant owns 12,111 . Approximately 40,000 acres of dispersal habitat, 18,646 acres YFM habitat, and 18,478 acres Sub-Mature habitat (Table 2-1). Within the White Salmon SOSEA there are 6,168 acres of dispersal habitat, 6,685 acres YFM habitat, and 5,885 acres Sub-Mature habitat. Of these acres, only 3,694 acres are considered unavailable for harvest by State and Federal regulatory restrictions because the habitat occurs within 0.7 mile radius circles and/or is considered the highest quality habitat within 1.8 mile radius circles (Section 2.11 below). Dispersal habitat is not considered restricted from harvest. Thus, 15,044 acres in the White Salmon SOSEA are available for harvest older forests will be harvested in the next 10 years under the No Action Alternative10-15 years. At the time of drafting the SHA and Harvest at this EA, WDNR has not identified the restricted habitat in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA. In the absence of this data, Applicants are assuming that all of their 1,003 acres of habitat in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA is also restricted resulting level will result in a total of 4,697 acres of spotted owl habitat remaining across all covered lands, 3,694 acres of which will be in the SOSEAs as White Salmon SOSEA, with the remainder in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA, i.e., areas currently restricted under existing regulatory mechanisms. In the period from harvest. All other habitat 20-60 years into the future, the Applicants will manage their commercial forestlands on a 45-year rotation ensuring no forest stands greater than 45 years of age occur on the Applicants ownership is available for harvest landscape except in riparian buffers and other sensitive areas that require retention of trees to protect unique ecological values. Snag retention, as they are available, and green trees retained to become older ‘wildlife trees,’ will be provided as required by the Oregon and Washington Forest Practices Rules under the No Action Alternative. Non Habitat (However, these would only be the minimums required and often times do not include any snags because of forest conditions created by previous regeneration harvests. The landscape will, thus, be a mixture of young forest age classes distributed across the landscape. Understory vegetation associated with older forests will be eliminated as these stands are harvested. Of the special-status plant species that may occur in the covered area, only tall bugbane and clustered lady's-slipper are associated with mature forests. Under the No Action Alternative, habitat for these species would be limited and likely reduced as mature forest stands that constitutes spotted owl habitat is removed. However, it is possible that some forest stands containing these plant species will remain if they are located in or adjacent to riparian buffers or in leave tree areas required under Oregon and Washington Forest Practices Rules. Western wahoo, which is associated with moist draws and ravines, is most likely to occur in RMZs and would receive some protection, depending on the stream type. Forest edge habitat for common blue-cup would occur along edges of early seral forest. Potential habitat for ▇▇▇▇▇▇▇’▇ quillwort may be protected if it is located within an RMZ; however, if it occurs in forested wetlands it may or may not be protected because under Forest Practices Rules forested wetlands are not protected from harvest unless they are bogs. The No Action Alternative may be advantageous for branching montia, which occurs in disturbed areas, as the frequency of ground disturbance within a given area would be greater under the No Action Alternative because of the shorter regeneration-harvest rotation. This increase in frequency and amount of ground disturbance could make it less than 39 yrs. old) 9,822 10,929 20,751 Dispersal (40likely that the four special-59 yrs. old) 6,168 5,943 12,111 Young Forest Marginal (typed by DNR & or 60-79 yrs.)1 6,685 11,961 18,646 Submature + (typed by DNR & or over 79 yrs. old)1,2 5,885 12,593 18,478 1 - habitat within owl circles typed by DNR; outside of owl circles age was used to type habitat 2 - includes Old Forest Habitat 3 - 741 acres Submature & 2,953 acres YFM 4 - 313 acres Submature & 690 acres YFM in Columbia Gorge SOSEAstatus plant species not associated with disturbed sites would persist if they currently inhabit the covered area.

Appears in 1 contract

Sources: Northern Spotted Owl Safe Harbor Agreement

No Action Alternative. Under the No Action Alternative, the proposed SHA would not be implemented and the USFWS would not issue Permits a Permit to the Applicants. Under this alternative, the Applicants would continue to conduct their forest management activities in accordance with applicable Forest Practices Rules in Oregon and Washington (Sections 2.1.1 and 2.1.2 below), and would avoid take of the northern spotted owl by not harvesting the 4,697 acres of suitable owl that is currently restricted from harvest under Washington Forest Practices Rules. The Applicants would implement an approximate 45-year timber-harvest rotation. When forest stands, or appropriately sized patches of forest, reach 45 years of age, they would be harvested for regeneration. SDS and BLC would conduct pre-commercial thinning, and commercial thinning would be conducted where economically practicable as part of their forest management plan, but not to accelerate spotted owl habitat growth under the No Action Alternative. The following list briefly describes the forest management activities associated with the No Action Alternative. Not all of the conservation activities that are associated with standard Washington Forest Practices Rules (WAC Title 222) are identified below, however, however any that are not included would apply equally to both alternatives. General forest management activities on commercial forests in Washington and Oregon:  plant and monitor until “free to grow”; controlling competing vegetation as needed;  pre-commercial thinning at 10-12 years old where conditions warrant it;  commercial thin where economically practical, but not to accelerate Young Forest Marginal (YFM) habitat;  monitor stand health and damage, and salvage opportunistically to recover value;  conduct regeneration harvest at an average age of 45 years; and  construct and maintain roads for forest management access. Wildlife Reserve Tree Management (WAC 222-30-020):  For each acre harvested in Eastern Washington, leave 2 wildlife reserve trees(>10 feet tall and >10 inches DBH), 2 green recruitment trees(>10 feet tall and >12 inches DBH), and 2 down logs(> 20 feet long and >12 inches diameter at small end). Northern spotted owl habitat conservation (WAC ▇▇▇-▇▇-▇▇, and ORS 527.610):  Retain 2,605 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat within 1.8 mile radius circles of owl site centers associated with SOSEAs. There are 18 of these circles that intersect with the applicants lands and a total of 4,697 acres of their lands have been identified as or are assumed to be part of this retention requirement in the White Salmon (14 circles and 3,694 acres) and Columbia Gorge (4 circles and 1,003 acres) SOSEAs;  Retention acres identified above are to include all suitable spotted owl habitat within 0.7 mile radius circles of owl site centers associated with SOSEAs. There are eight 0.7 mile radius circles that intersect with the applicants lands in the White Salmon SOSEA (see Table 2-2);  Outside of SOSEAS in Washington, during the nesting season, retain 70 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat surrounding a northern spotted owl site center. Currently there are no known spotted owl activity centers on the Applicants’ lands in Washington outside of the SOSEAs; and  In Oregon, retain 70 acres of the highest quality suitable spotted owl habitat surrounding a northern spotted owl site center. Currently there are no known spotted owl activity centers on the Applicants’ lands in Oregon. SDS’ commercial forestland, defined as productive timberlands suitable for forestry, totals 46,244 acres in Washington and 12,141 acres in Oregon. BLC has 11,601 acres of commercial forestland in Washington (See SHA Figure 2-1 and SHA Table 3-1). The baseline includes all commercial forestland that the Applicants could harvest in Washington and Oregon under the current state Forest Practices Rules. Under Forest Practices Rules in Oregon, spotted owls are protected only where there is an active spotted owl nesting site or activity center occupied by a pair of adult owls capable of breeding. Protection of a 70-acre core area around the spotted owl nest site is required during the breeding season. Although, there are six spotted owl sites of unknown status and occupancy on USFS land in proximity to SDS lands, none of the 70-acre cores intersect SDS lands. Oregon Department of Forestry and USFWS records indicate that there are no known spotted owl nests on the Applicants land in Oregon. Applicants have covered lands outside of SOSEAs that consists of 47,523 acres (60% of which is in Washington and 40% in Oregon). Applicants’ commercial forestland outside of SOSEAs is 38,499 acres (SHA Table 3-1). Except for the restrictions on harvest of spotted owl habitat in the SOSEAs, the Applicants may harvest all suitable habitat on their ownership in Oregon and Washington under the No Action Alternative. Therefore, under the No Action Alternative, the Applicants’ current forest management regime in Oregon will focus timber harvest efforts on all stands that qualify as owl habitat with the goal of eliminating suitable spotted owl habitat within the next 10 years. The Applicants state that due to regulatory uncertainty they have substantially increased the rate of harvest as part of their strategy to harvest their most mature stands within the constraints of the Forest Practice Rules. This includes managing their lands on a 45-year rotation, harvesting surplus habitat (in excess of highest quality 2,605 acres) within 1.8 mile circles, and harvesting all spotted owl habitat outside of the 1.8 mile circles over the next 10 years. Applicants state they are strategically harvesting the highest quality habitat as early as possible. In addition to this management approach, the Applicants are not allowing non-habitat within spotted owl circles to grow into suitable owl habitat to avoid additional regulatory burdens. Currently, across all the covered lands, the Applicant owns 12,111 acres of dispersal habitat, 18,646 acres YFM habitat, and 18,478 acres Sub-Mature mature habitat (Table 2-1). Within the White Salmon SOSEA there are 6,168 acres of dispersal habitat, 6,685 acres YFM habitat, and 5,885 acres Sub-Mature mature habitat. Of these acres, only 3,694 acres are considered unavailable for harvest by State and Federal regulatory restrictions because the habitat occurs within 0.7 mile radius circles and/or is considered the highest quality habitat within 1.8 mile radius circles (Section 2.11 below). Dispersal habitat is not considered restricted from harvest. Thus, 15,044 acres in the White Salmon SOSEA are available for harvest in the next 10 years under the No Action Alternative. At the time of drafting the SHA and this EA, WDNR has not identified the restricted habitat in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA. In the absence of this data, Applicants are assuming that all of their 1,003 acres of habitat in the Columbia Gorge SOSEA is also restricted resulting in a total of 4,697 acres of habitat in the SOSEAs as restricted from harvest. All other habitat on the Applicants ownership is available for harvest under the No Action Alternative. Non Habitat (less than 39 yrs. old) 9,822 10,929 20,751 Dispersal (40-59 yrs. old) 6,168 5,943 12,111 Young Forest Marginal (typed by DNR & or 60-79 yrs.)1 6,685 11,961 18,646 Submature + (typed by DNR & or over 79 yrs. old)1,2 5,885 12,593 18,478 1 - habitat within owl circles typed by DNR; outside of owl circles age was used to type habitat 2 - includes Old Forest Habitat 3 - 741 acres Submature & 2,953 acres YFM 4 - 313 acres Submature & 690 acres YFM in Columbia Gorge SOSEA

Appears in 1 contract

Sources: Northern Spotted Owl Safe Harbor Agreement