{"component": "clause", "props": {"groups": [{"size": 722, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [3, 14]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [15, 24]}, {"key": "sum-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [57, 63]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [84, 93]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [136, 145]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [163, 180]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [227, 239]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [300, 317]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [400, 411]}, {"key": "no-legal-obligation", "type": "clause", "offset": [461, 480]}, {"key": "legally-required", "type": "clause", "offset": [626, 642]}, {"key": "the-provisions-of-this", "type": "clause", "offset": [656, 678]}], "snippet": "If at any time a dispute shall arise as to any amount or sum of money to be paid by one Party to the other under the provisions hereof, the Party against whom the obligation to pay the money is asserted shall have the right to make payment \"under protest\" and such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment and there shall survive the right on the part of said Party to institute suit for recovery of such sum. If it shall be adjudged that there was no legal obligation on the part of said Party to pay such sum or any part thereof, said Party shall be entitled to recover such sum or so much thereof as it was not legally required to pay under the provisions of this Lease.", "samples": [{"hash": "8rjbSjSclnd", "uri": "/contracts/8rjbSjSclnd#performance-under-protest", "label": "Annual Report", "score": 23.635181427, "published": true}, {"hash": "1bHbcUFr1fL", "uri": "/contracts/1bHbcUFr1fL#performance-under-protest", "label": "Form 10 K/A", "score": 23.635181427, "published": true}, {"hash": "8gnTPWtl98", "uri": "/contracts/8gnTPWtl98#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement (Spectranetics Corp)", "score": 23.6078033447, "published": true}], "hash": "e3600c6ecd122d009574150cab46befe", "id": 1}, {"size": 143, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [3, 14]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [15, 24]}, {"key": "sum-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [57, 63]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [84, 93]}, {"key": "the-provisions", "type": "clause", "offset": [113, 127]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [136, 145]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [163, 180]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [227, 239]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [300, 317]}, {"key": "no-legal-obligation", "type": "clause", "offset": [461, 480]}, {"key": "legally-required", "type": "clause", "offset": [626, 642]}, {"key": "a-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [651, 658]}, {"key": "recovery-of-sums", "type": "clause", "offset": [694, 710]}, {"key": "right-to-protest", "type": "clause", "offset": [783, 799]}], "snippet": "If at any time a dispute shall arise as to any amount or sum of money to be paid by one Party to the other under the provisions hereof, the Party against whom the obligation to pay the money is asserted shall have the right to make payment \u201cunder protest\u201d and such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment and there shall survive the right on the part of said Party to institute suit for recovery of such sum. If it shall be adjudged that there was no legal obligation on the part of said Party to pay such sum or any part thereof, said Party shall be entitled to recover such sum or so much thereof as it was not legally required to pay. A Party who does not initiate suit for the recovery of sums paid \u201cunder protest\u201d within 6 months shall be deemed to have waived its right to protest such payment.", "samples": [{"hash": "gN2f3r5RCDM", "uri": "/contracts/gN2f3r5RCDM#performance-under-protest", "label": "Office Lease (Vickers Vantage Corp. I)", "score": 33.5503082275, "published": true}, {"hash": "jtGwrnRHMc1", "uri": "/contracts/jtGwrnRHMc1#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement (Brownie's Marine Group, Inc)", "score": 33.35181427, "published": true}, {"hash": "g18tfyuDyWK", "uri": "/contracts/g18tfyuDyWK#performance-under-protest", "label": "Standard Multi Tenant Office Lease (America Great Health)", "score": 33.1026687622, "published": true}], "hash": "cede19e6871ceadf09961a3ea34b1ffa", "id": 2}, {"size": 6, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [8, 19]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [20, 29]}, {"key": "sum-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [62, 68]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [89, 98]}, {"key": "other-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [106, 117]}, {"key": "the-provisions", "type": "clause", "offset": [124, 138]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [147, 156]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [174, 191]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [238, 250]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [311, 328]}, {"key": "subject-to-the", "type": "definition", "offset": [335, 349]}, {"key": "conditions-of-this", "type": "clause", "offset": [366, 384]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [475, 486]}], "snippet": "22.1 If at any time a dispute shall arise as to any amount or sum of money to be paid by one party to the other party under the provisions hereof, the party against whom the obligation to pay the money is asserted shall have the right to make payment \u201cunder protest\u201d and such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment, and, subject to the other terms and conditions of this Lease, there shall survive the right on the part of said party to in\u00adstitute suit for the recovery of such sum.", "samples": [{"hash": "75mYI7ZBVkl", "uri": "/contracts/75mYI7ZBVkl#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement (Chicago Pizza & Brewery Inc)", "score": 21.0, "published": true}], "hash": "a8dbe5b98cfedf145e1e19c0896e56b7", "id": 7}, {"size": 28, "snippet_links": [{"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [3, 12]}, {"key": "under-this-lease", "type": "clause", "offset": [60, 76]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [78, 87]}, {"key": "right-to-perform", "type": "clause", "offset": [145, 161]}, {"key": "a-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [234, 241]}, {"key": "appropriate-proceedings", "type": "definition", "offset": [289, 312]}, {"key": "amount-paid", "type": "definition", "offset": [328, 339]}, {"key": "cost-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [358, 365]}, {"key": "complying-with", "type": "clause", "offset": [376, 390]}, {"key": "with-interest", "type": "definition", "offset": [412, 425]}, {"key": "the-prime-rate", "type": "definition", "offset": [429, 443]}], "snippet": "If a dispute arises regarding performance of any obligation under this Lease, the party against which such obligation is asserted shall have the right to perform it under protest, which shall not be regarded as voluntary performance. A party that has performed under protest may institute appropriate proceedings to recover any amount paid or the reasonable cost of otherwise complying with any such obligation, with interest at the Prime Rate.", "samples": [{"hash": "67odx4rcMLb", "uri": "/contracts/67odx4rcMLb#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement", "score": 33.1193771362, "published": true}, {"hash": "5VPIoMU3jTr", "uri": "/contracts/5VPIoMU3jTr#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement", "score": 27.535112381, "published": true}, {"hash": "dBYw7GQasIU", "uri": "/contracts/dBYw7GQasIU#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement", "score": 25.283367157, "published": true}], "hash": "ba27905d6afd5f980f94ea160a24876c", "id": 4}, {"size": 5, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [3, 14]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [15, 24]}, {"key": "sum-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [57, 63]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [84, 93]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [136, 145]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [163, 180]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [227, 239]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [300, 317]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [400, 411]}, {"key": "no-legal-obligation", "type": "clause", "offset": [461, 480]}, {"key": "legally-required", "type": "clause", "offset": [626, 642]}, {"key": "the-provisions-of-this", "type": "clause", "offset": [656, 678]}], "snippet": "If at any time a dispute shall arise as to any amount or sum of money to be paid by one Party to the other under the provisions hereof, the party against whom the obligation to pay the money is asserted shall have the right to make payment \"under protest\" and such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment and there shall survive the right on the part of said party to institute suit for recovery of such sum. If it shall be adjudged that there was no legal obligation on the part of said Party to pay such sum or any part thereof, said Party shall be entitled to recover such sum or so much thereof as it was not legally required to pay under the provisions of this Lease.", "samples": [{"hash": "3eulMlMkJe0", "uri": "/contracts/3eulMlMkJe0#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement (BGF Industries Inc)", "score": 18.0, "published": true}], "hash": "8434f12c562a5c40fd002475b6c0bf1c", "id": 8}, {"size": 6, "snippet_links": [{"key": "in-the-event-of-a-dispute", "type": "clause", "offset": [0, 25]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [153, 162]}, {"key": "the-right", "type": "clause", "offset": [215, 224]}, {"key": "the-obligation", "type": "clause", "offset": [264, 278]}, {"key": "a-volunteer", "type": "clause", "offset": [327, 338]}, {"key": "the-claim", "type": "definition", "offset": [385, 394]}, {"key": "right-to", "type": "definition", "offset": [415, 423]}, {"key": "action-at-law", "type": "clause", "offset": [445, 458]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [506, 517]}, {"key": "in-the-performance", "type": "clause", "offset": [536, 554]}, {"key": "successful-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [591, 607]}, {"key": "in-addition-to", "type": "clause", "offset": [637, 651]}, {"key": "other-recoveries", "type": "clause", "offset": [656, 672]}, {"key": "reasonable-attorneys", "type": "definition", "offset": [678, 698]}, {"key": "by-the-court", "type": "clause", "offset": [723, 735]}], "snippet": "In the event of a dispute or difference between City and PWRF as to any obligation which either may assert the other is obligated to perform or do, then the party against whom such obligation is asserted shall have the right and privilege to carry out and perform the obligation so asserted against it without being considered a volunteer or deemed to have admitted the correctness of the claim, and shall have the right to bring an appropriate action at law, equity or otherwise against the other for the recovery of any sums expended in the performance thereof and in any such action, the successful party shall be entitled to recover in addition to all other recoveries such reasonable attorneys' fees as may be awarded by the court.", "samples": [{"hash": "lHSYHB8khuJ", "uri": "/contracts/lHSYHB8khuJ#performance-under-protest", "label": "Public Use Covenant", "score": 35.5255889893, "published": true}, {"hash": "ivE5DV3tukb", "uri": "/contracts/ivE5DV3tukb#performance-under-protest", "label": "Public Use Covenant", "score": 35.4081764221, "published": true}, {"hash": "bMqGmP5iQ5S", "uri": "/contracts/bMqGmP5iQ5S#performance-under-protest", "label": "Public Use Covenant", "score": 35.3640213013, "published": true}], "hash": "5e485a5d6df2e0dfe5761d1c464bff61", "id": 6}, {"size": 9, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [3, 14]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [15, 24]}, {"key": "sum-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [57, 63]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [84, 93]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [136, 145]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [163, 180]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [227, 239]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [300, 317]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [401, 412]}, {"key": "no-legal-obligation", "type": "clause", "offset": [462, 481]}, {"key": "legally-required", "type": "clause", "offset": [627, 643]}, {"key": "the-provisions-of-this", "type": "clause", "offset": [657, 679]}, {"key": "estate-association", "type": "definition", "offset": [783, 801]}], "snippet": "If at any time a dispute shall arise as to any amount or sum of money to be paid by one party to the other under the provisions hereof, the party against whom the obligation to pay the money is asserted shall have the right to make payment \"under protest\" and such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment, and there shall survive the right on the part of said party to institute suit for recovery of such sum. If it shall be adjudged that there was no legal obligation on the part of said party to pay such sum or any part thereof, said party shall be entitled to recover such sum or so much thereof as it was not legally required to pay under the provisions of this Lease. Initials:/s/ DM ------- /s/ JWB ------- MULTI TENANT--MODIFIED NET -C- American Industrial Real Estate Association 1981", "samples": [{"hash": "iOULLAX4Sbx", "uri": "/contracts/iOULLAX4Sbx#performance-under-protest", "label": "Standard Industrial Lease (Qad Inc)", "score": 18.0, "published": true}, {"hash": "g04KtWBcEqk", "uri": "/contracts/g04KtWBcEqk#performance-under-protest", "label": "Standard Industrial Lease (Qad Inc)", "score": 18.0, "published": true}], "hash": "525e43f308fedf37f9c3a7052398b0ca", "id": 5}, {"size": 44, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [3, 14]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [15, 24]}, {"key": "sum-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [57, 63]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [84, 93]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [136, 145]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [163, 180]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [227, 239]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [300, 317]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [401, 412]}, {"key": "no-legal-obligation", "type": "clause", "offset": [462, 481]}, {"key": "the-provisions-of-this", "type": "clause", "offset": [659, 681]}], "snippet": "If at any time a dispute shall arise as to any amount or sum of money to be paid by one party to the other under the provisions hereof, the party against whom the obligation to pay the money is asserted shall have the right to make payment \"under protest\" and such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment, and there shall survive the right on the part of said party to institute suit for recovery of such sum. If it shall be adjudged that there was no legal obligation on the part of said party to pay such sum or any part thereof, said party shall be entitled to recover such sum or so much thereof as it was not legally required13 to pay under the provisions of this Lease.", "samples": [{"hash": "61WPQFFrdDR", "uri": "/contracts/61WPQFFrdDR#performance-under-protest", "label": "Industrial Lease (Golden West Brewing Company, Inc.)", "score": 19.0, "published": true}], "hash": "f2313d0403225e0cf9a104801860df2a", "id": 3}, {"size": 5, "snippet_links": [], "snippet": "39 44. Authority....................................................................... 39", "samples": [{"hash": "l7Bz0tS0lbj", "uri": "/contracts/l7Bz0tS0lbj#performance-under-protest", "label": "Lease Agreement (Skechers Usa Inc)", "score": 18.0, "published": true}], "hash": "a961f04e3d55162f1395e54257a380c1", "id": 9}, {"size": 4, "snippet_links": [{"key": "at-any-time", "type": "clause", "offset": [3, 14]}, {"key": "a-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [15, 24]}, {"key": "payment-to", "type": "clause", "offset": [61, 71]}, {"key": "one-party", "type": "definition", "offset": [83, 92]}, {"key": "the-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [133, 142]}, {"key": "obligation-to-pay", "type": "clause", "offset": [160, 177]}, {"key": "make-payment", "type": "definition", "offset": [214, 226]}, {"key": "voluntary-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [284, 301]}, {"key": "the-payment", "type": "clause", "offset": [320, 331]}, {"key": "right-to-institute-suit", "type": "clause", "offset": [359, 382]}, {"key": "recovery-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [387, 398]}, {"key": "to-the-extent", "type": "clause", "offset": [409, 422]}, {"key": "not-required", "type": "definition", "offset": [505, 517]}, {"key": "such-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [540, 550]}, {"key": "legally-required", "type": "clause", "offset": [634, 650]}, {"key": "pursuant-to-this-agreement", "type": "clause", "offset": [658, 684]}, {"key": "interest-on", "type": "definition", "offset": [700, 711]}, {"key": "the-prime-rate", "type": "definition", "offset": [732, 746]}], "snippet": "If at any time a dispute shall arise as to the amount of any payment to be made by one party to the other under this Agreement, then the party against whom the obligation to pay is asserted shall have the right to make payment \"under protest\". Such payment shall not be regarded as a voluntary payment. The party making the payment shall continue to have the right to institute suit for recovery of such sum. To the extent that it shall be determined that the party making the payment \"under protest\" was not required to make such payment, such party shall be entitled to recover such sum or so much of such sum as such party was not legally required to pay pursuant to this Agreement, together with interest on such overpayment at the Prime Rate.", "samples": [{"hash": "3bVMeEEewgo", "uri": "/contracts/3bVMeEEewgo#performance-under-protest", "label": "Master Real Estate Transfer, Franchise and Lease Agreement (HGI - Lakeside)", "score": 21.0, "published": true}], "hash": "f02fac775016fe51875c2f4642d52134", "id": 10}], "next_curs": "CmISXGoVc35sYXdpbnNpZGVyY29udHJhY3Rzcj4LEhZDbGF1c2VTbmlwcGV0R3JvdXBfdjU2IiJwZXJmb3JtYW5jZS11bmRlci1wcm90ZXN0IzAwMDAwMDBhDKIBAmVuGAAgAA==", "clause": {"size": 977, "parents": [["miscellaneous", "Miscellaneous"], ["miscellaneous-provisions", "Miscellaneous Provisions"], ["successors-and-assigns", "Successors and Assigns"], ["whereas", "WHEREAS"], ["general-provisions", "General Provisions"]], "title": "Performance Under Protest", "children": [["", ""], ["colors", "Colors"], ["lease-commencement-date", "LEASE COMMENCEMENT DATE"], ["lessors-obligation", "LESSOR'S OBLIGATION"], ["graphics", "Graphics"]], "id": "performance-under-protest", "related": [["posting-of-recommended-award-and-protests", "POSTING OF RECOMMENDED AWARD AND PROTESTS", "POSTING OF RECOMMENDED AWARD AND PROTESTS"], ["performance-by-borrower", "Performance by Borrower", "Performance by Borrower"], ["suspension-of-performance-disbursement-into-court", "Suspension of Performance Disbursement Into Court", "Suspension of Performance Disbursement Into Court"], ["grant-of-performance-units", "Grant of Performance Units", "Grant of Performance Units"], ["suspension-of-performance-or-disbursement-into-court", "Suspension of Performance or Disbursement Into Court", "Suspension of Performance or Disbursement Into Court"]], "related_snippets": [], "updated": "2026-06-09T05:48:27+00:00", "also_ask": ["How can 'performance under protest' preserve rights while avoiding waiver of claims?", "What essential language must be included to ensure the protest is legally recognized?", "What are the main risks if the protest is not clearly communicated or documented?", "How do courts in key jurisdictions interpret and enforce 'performance under protest' clauses?", "How does this clause interact with doctrines like accord and satisfaction or estoppel?"], "drafting_tip": "Specify procedures for protesting performance to preserve rights, require written notice to create a clear record, and define consequences to avoid disputes over waiver or acceptance.", "explanation": "The \"Performance Under Protest\" clause allows a party to fulfill its contractual obligations while explicitly reserving the right to dispute certain terms, conditions, or requirements. In practice, this means that a party may proceed with performance\u2014such as delivering goods or services\u2014even if it disagrees with an interpretation of the contract or a directive from the other party, provided it clearly communicates its protest. This clause is essential for preventing a waiver of rights or acceptance of disputed terms, ensuring that parties can comply with contractual duties without forfeiting their ability to seek resolution or assert claims regarding contested issues."}, "json": true, "cursor": ""}}