{"component": "clause", "props": {"groups": [{"size": 9, "snippet": "The parties will not cite exhaustive arbitral jurisprudence but will normally refer to \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 & \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 or \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 for summary purposes.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "the-parties-will", "type": "clause", "offset": [0, 16]}, {"key": "refer-to", "type": "definition", "offset": [78, 86]}], "samples": [{"hash": "gNpJZBzOHav", "uri": "/contracts/gNpJZBzOHav#argument", "label": "Collective Agreement", "score": 23.714761734, "published": true}, {"hash": "amYjpyW4D9z", "uri": "/contracts/amYjpyW4D9z#argument", "label": "Collective Agreement", "score": 20.8706378937, "published": true}, {"hash": "gACVJ6GEAWj", "uri": "/contracts/gACVJ6GEAWj#argument", "label": "Collective Agreement", "score": 20.245721817, "published": true}], "hash": "034b0453d13d5d07191ec67e572a378a", "id": 1}, {"size": 5, "snippet": "Oral argument or briefs on a motion may be ordered by the As- sistant Administrator or the adminis- trative law judge.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "oral-argument", "type": "definition", "offset": [0, 13]}, {"key": "ordered-by", "type": "definition", "offset": [43, 53]}], "samples": [{"hash": "9AjDdLRl7QW", "uri": "/contracts/9AjDdLRl7QW#argument", "label": "Settlement Agreement", "score": 31.5836791992, "published": true}, {"hash": "jSzqiFLCSXA", "uri": "/contracts/jSzqiFLCSXA#argument", "label": "Settlement Agreement", "score": 29.0680370331, "published": true}, {"hash": "jJz4MVXB2VM", "uri": "/contracts/jJz4MVXB2VM#argument", "label": "Settlement Agreement", "score": 25.7556476593, "published": true}], "hash": "1fe23fff823e0e863124852b841a3e0b", "id": 2}, {"size": 3, "snippet": "argument of the complaining Party;", "snippet_links": [{"key": "complaining-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [16, 33]}], "samples": [{"hash": "le76lEmCe5F", "uri": "/contracts/le76lEmCe5F#argument", "label": "Free Trade Agreement", "score": 29.9073944092, "published": true}, {"hash": "b7nIkKn1WhA", "uri": "/contracts/b7nIkKn1WhA#argument", "label": "Eu Australia Free Trade Agreement Proposal", "score": 24.2874736786, "published": true}, {"hash": "3iftYfFIpI3", "uri": "/contracts/3iftYfFIpI3#argument", "label": "Dispute Settlement Agreement", "score": 24.2737846375, "published": true}], "hash": "bea516efb69f7128430b52723cec90aa", "id": 3}, {"size": 3, "snippet": "As noted above, this case is in its early stages of discovery and involves a complex subject matter and dozens of parties. In an effort to minimize judicial intervention in the discovery process and better streamline the production of documents and information, Plaintiffs circulated a proposed stipulated Protective Order (Ex. A), a Clawback Agreement (Ex. B), and an ESI Protocol (Ex. C) to all parties. These proposed discovery protocols lay out the handling of protected information and documents, the process for handling inadvertent productions of privileged or confidential information, as well as the method for preserving ESI, collecting and exchanging search terms for ESI, the form of production, prior productions, the handling of privileged information, and more. ELECTRONICALLY FILED - 2024 Aug 22 11:08 AM - CHARLESTON - COMMON PLEAS - CASE#2023CP1002574 These protocols lay out, in detail, proposed plans and limitations on discovery, as well as the form of production and other issues relating to ESI and protocols for claims of privilege or protection of requested information. These proposed protocols lay out, in detail, all of the information required under Rule 26(f) for the setting of a discovery conference. Plaintiffs have made multiple good faith efforts to reach agreement with opposing attorneys on the issues presented in this motion. Plaintiffs have circulated proposed stipulated protective orders and ESI protocols to all parties on multiple occasions requesting and implementing feedback as it is received. Plaintiffs also circulated the latest forms of the Protective Order (Ex. A), Clawback Agreement (Ex. B), and ESI Protocol (Ex. C) on August 14, 2024, requesting that the Parties advise whether they consent or object to same. Plaintiffs received a response from the original developer, Defendant 10 West Edge Owner, LLC providing its consent to the Clawback Agreement and entry of the proposed Protective Order and ESI Protocol. Plaintiffs have not received a response from the remaining Defendants advising whether they consent or object to the proposed Protective Order, Clawback Agreement, and ESI Protocol in their current forms. Thus, Plaintiffs believe that a discovery conference before the Court will encourage open discussion between all parties to come to an agreement on proper discovery protocols to better streamline the discovery process given the complexity of the case.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "subject-matter", "type": "definition", "offset": [85, 99]}, {"key": "judicial-intervention", "type": "clause", "offset": [148, 169]}, {"key": "documents-and-information", "type": "clause", "offset": [235, 260]}, {"key": "a-proposed", "type": "clause", "offset": [284, 294]}, {"key": "stipulated-protective-order", "type": "clause", "offset": [295, 322]}, {"key": "clawback-agreement", "type": "definition", "offset": [334, 352]}, {"key": "all-parties", "type": "clause", "offset": [393, 404]}, {"key": "lay-out", "type": "clause", "offset": [441, 448]}, {"key": "information-and-documents", "type": "clause", "offset": [475, 500]}, {"key": "the-process", "type": "clause", "offset": [502, 513]}, {"key": "privileged-or-confidential-information", "type": "definition", "offset": [554, 592]}, {"key": "the-method", "type": "definition", "offset": [605, 615]}, {"key": "terms-for", "type": "definition", "offset": [669, 678]}, {"key": "form-of-production", "type": "clause", "offset": [688, 706]}, {"key": "handling-of-privileged-information", "type": "clause", "offset": [731, 765]}, {"key": "electronically-filed", "type": "definition", "offset": [777, 797]}, {"key": "in-detail", "type": "clause", "offset": [895, 904]}, {"key": "plans-and", "type": "definition", "offset": [915, 924]}, {"key": "limitations-on", "type": "clause", "offset": [925, 939]}, {"key": "other-issues", "type": "definition", "offset": [989, 1001]}, {"key": "relating-to", "type": "definition", "offset": [1002, 1013]}, {"key": "claims-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [1036, 1045]}, {"key": "protection-of", "type": "definition", "offset": [1059, 1072]}, {"key": "requested-information", "type": "definition", "offset": [1073, 1094]}, {"key": "information-required", "type": "clause", "offset": [1152, 1172]}, {"key": "under-rule", "type": "clause", "offset": [1173, 1183]}, {"key": "good-faith-efforts", "type": "clause", "offset": [1263, 1281]}, {"key": "the-issues", "type": "clause", "offset": [1328, 1338]}, {"key": "protective-orders", "type": "definition", "offset": [1412, 1429]}, {"key": "the-parties", "type": "definition", "offset": [1707, 1718]}, {"key": "original-developer", "type": "definition", "offset": [1806, 1824]}, {"key": "consent-to", "type": "clause", "offset": [1874, 1884]}, {"key": "the-proposed", "type": "clause", "offset": [1921, 1933]}, {"key": "the-court", "type": "clause", "offset": [2234, 2243]}, {"key": "open-discussion", "type": "definition", "offset": [2259, 2274]}, {"key": "an-agreement", "type": "clause", "offset": [2306, 2318]}, {"key": "the-case", "type": "definition", "offset": [2416, 2424]}], "samples": [{"hash": "kihyBvdPzVh", "uri": "/contracts/kihyBvdPzVh#argument", "label": "Legal Complaint", "score": 33.7370834351, "published": true}, {"hash": "ahuznbK3fKH", "uri": "/contracts/ahuznbK3fKH#argument", "label": "Legal Complaint", "score": 33.6488800049, "published": true}, {"hash": "hm0YKNKvy6m", "uri": "/contracts/hm0YKNKvy6m#argument", "label": "Legal Complaint", "score": 33.5808830261, "published": true}], "hash": "3037b8bf8b3f856852827d158e0cd8a8", "id": 4}, {"size": 3, "snippet": "THE STANDARD OF REVIEW This Court reviews the district court's granting of the preliminary injunction under an \"abuse of discretion standard.\" \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 \u2587. PUBLIC EMPLOYEE RET. HEALTH SYS. OF OHIO, 160 F.3d 310, 312 (6th Cir. 1998). Such injunctions \"will seldom be disturbed unless the district court relied upon clearly erroneous findings of fact, improperly applied the governing law, or used an erroneous legal standard. ID. (citing BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD MUT. OF OHIO V. BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD ASS'N, 110 F.3d 318, 322 (6th Cir. 1997)). Appellate courts afford district courts' decisions to grant preliminary injunctions \"great deference,\" BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD MUT. OF OHIO, 110 F.3d at 322, and \"will reverse a district court's balancing of the equities only in the rarest of circumstances.\" \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587, 160 F.3d at 313. As shown below, the district court properly granted SPG's motion for a preliminary injunction.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "standard-of-review", "type": "clause", "offset": [4, 22]}, {"key": "this-court", "type": "definition", "offset": [23, 33]}, {"key": "the-district", "type": "clause", "offset": [42, 54]}, {"key": "the-preliminary", "type": "clause", "offset": [75, 90]}, {"key": "abuse-of-discretion", "type": "definition", "offset": [112, 131]}, {"key": "public-employee", "type": "definition", "offset": [153, 168]}, {"key": "clearly-erroneous", "type": "definition", "offset": [311, 328]}, {"key": "findings-of-fact", "type": "definition", "offset": [329, 345]}, {"key": "the-governing-law", "type": "clause", "offset": [366, 383]}, {"key": "legal-standard", "type": "clause", "offset": [406, 420]}, {"key": "blue-cross", "type": "clause", "offset": [434, 444]}, {"key": "blue-shield", "type": "definition", "offset": [447, 458]}, {"key": "appellate-courts", "type": "definition", "offset": [543, 559]}, {"key": "district-courts", "type": "clause", "offset": [567, 582]}, {"key": "preliminary-injunctions", "type": "clause", "offset": [603, 626]}, {"key": "as-shown", "type": "definition", "offset": [828, 836]}], "samples": [{"hash": "6JwLby9swrL", "uri": "/contracts/6JwLby9swrL#argument", "label": "Final Brief (Simon Property Group Inc /De/)", "score": 16.0, "published": true}], "hash": "dfd15b08afc1316a85beb2796eb9e4e8", "id": 5}, {"size": 2, "snippet": "21 The 2015 Decision should be upheld because it properly addressed the two key issues that\nC. District Court ordered the Secretary to reconsider: whether the Tribe\u2019s membership was 23 limited to five people, and whether the 1998 Resolution established a valid Tribal government.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "key-issues", "type": "clause", "offset": [76, 86]}, {"key": "court-ordered", "type": "definition", "offset": [104, 117]}, {"key": "the-secretary", "type": "clause", "offset": [118, 131]}, {"key": "established-a", "type": "definition", "offset": [241, 254]}, {"key": "tribal-government", "type": "clause", "offset": [261, 278]}], "samples": [{"hash": "jWNxaWw0c96", "uri": "/contracts/jWNxaWw0c96#argument", "label": "Legal Representation Agreement", "score": 24.1746406555, "published": true}, {"hash": "8PbJQ7WvGg7", "uri": "/contracts/8PbJQ7WvGg7#argument", "label": "Legal Representation Agreement", "score": 24.1746406555, "published": true}], "hash": "95b052f854354036e3b3cb3cda7bfc4e", "id": 6}, {"size": 2, "snippet": "There is no genuine dispute as to the basic facts of the challenged conduct.16 Respondents\u2019 rules and practices benefit ocean carriers while increasing costs to motor carriers, the shipping public, and ultimately American consumers. These practices are unnecessarily restrictive to accomplish the purported goals of the procurement of chassis and interoperable chassis pools. And ocean carriers\u2014as common carriers\u2014have a duty to the shipping public beyond maximizing short term profits at the expense of the rest of the supply chain. Nor can Respondents dispute the legal effect of these facts. Distribution Services is on all fours here. There, the Commission struck down an ocean carrier conference rule controlling reimbursement of \u201ctransshipment\u201d services, which governed the transfer of cargo from an ocean container to an inland container at an off-port location. That rule incentivized minimizing the transportation of empty ocean carrier containers back to port, shifting the cost of transporting empty containers elsewhere. Distribution Services, 1988 WL 340659, at *2. Although minimizing the transportation of empty ocean containers and preventing false billing were \u201cworthy objective[s],\u201d the Commission found the ocean carriers\u2019 regulations to be \u201cexcessive and thus unreasonable\u201d because \u201cless intrusive methods\u201d existed to accomplish those goals. Id. at *7. The same analysis applies here.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "genuine-dispute", "type": "definition", "offset": [12, 27]}, {"key": "basic-facts", "type": "clause", "offset": [38, 49]}, {"key": "rules-and-practices", "type": "clause", "offset": [92, 111]}, {"key": "motor-carriers", "type": "definition", "offset": [161, 175]}, {"key": "unnecessarily-restrictive", "type": "definition", "offset": [253, 278]}, {"key": "short-term", "type": "clause", "offset": [467, 477]}, {"key": "supply-chain", "type": "definition", "offset": [520, 532]}, {"key": "effect-of", "type": "definition", "offset": [572, 581]}, {"key": "distribution-services", "type": "definition", "offset": [595, 616]}, {"key": "the-commission", "type": "clause", "offset": [646, 660]}, {"key": "ocean-carrier", "type": "definition", "offset": [676, 689]}, {"key": "transfer-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [780, 791]}, {"key": "cost-of", "type": "definition", "offset": [984, 991]}, {"key": "empty-containers", "type": "clause", "offset": [1005, 1021]}], "samples": [{"hash": "bs64q77m6fY", "uri": "/contracts/bs64q77m6fY#argument", "label": "Consolidated Reply", "score": 34.2543334961, "published": true}], "hash": "28f397fdf6404b683aa182d69f9a0a59", "id": 7}, {"size": 2, "snippet": "i) Argument of the complaining Party\nii) Argument of the Party complained against. [iii) Argument of the Third Part (y) (ies)]", "snippet_links": [{"key": "complaining-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [19, 36]}, {"key": "party-complained-against", "type": "definition", "offset": [57, 81]}], "samples": [{"hash": "4lNypW8ewQF", "uri": "/contracts/4lNypW8ewQF#argument", "label": "Dispute Settlement Agreement", "score": 19.0, "published": true}], "hash": "dbb31a5476806ba2bc665ac7e4a54332", "id": 8}, {"size": 1, "snippet": "ASIC\u2019s Appeal is Subject to De Novo Review (Issue Not Raised Below) \u201cThe existence of a valid and enforceable arbitration agreement poses a question of law, and as such, [this Court's] review of an order denying a motion to compel arbitration is de novo.\u201d \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 \u2587. \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 & Co., Inc., 442 N.J. Super. 599, 605 (App. Div. 2015). See also \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 v. Pfizer, Inc., 244 N.J. 30, 46 (2020) (\u201cWhether a contractual arbitration provision is enforceable is a question of law, and we need not defer to the interpretative analysis of the trial or appellate courts unless we find it persuasive.\u201d) (citing to \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 v. Home Warranty Adm'r of Fla., Inc., 236 N.J. 301, 316 (2019) and \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 v. U.S. Legal Servs. Grp., L.P., 219 N.J. 430, 445-46 (2014). Further, the issue of whether a party waived its arbitration right is also subject to de novo review. Cole v. Jersey City Med. Ctr. , 215 N.J. 265, 275 (2013). Here, the trial court's denial of the Motion to Compel Arbitration on the grounds that ASIC waived its right to arbitrate and that the arbitration clauses do not apply here should not be given any special deference. The FAA governs the enforcement of the arbitration clauses in the ASIC policies, and state courts are required to \u201chonor and enforce agreements to arbitrate.\u201d \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 \u2587. Discover Bank, 556 U.S. 49, 71 (2009). The FAA applies to any contract \u201cevidencing a transaction involving commerce\u201d that is subject to a written agreement to arbitrate. See 9 U.S.C. \u00a7 2. The United States Supreme Court has held that the phrase \u201cinvolving commerce\u201d in the FAA is the \u201cfunctional equivalent of the more familiar term \u2018affecting commerce,\u2019\u201d which signals the broadest permissible exercise of Congress\u2019 Commerce Clause power. Citizens Bank v. Alafabco, Inc., \u2587\u2587\u2587 \u2587.\u2587. \u2587\u2587, \u2587\u2587 (2003) (citing Allied-\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 Cos., 513 U.S. 265, 273\u201374 (1995). Here, ASIC is an Illinois corporation headquartered in New York. Newport Associates Development Company is a New Jersey general partnership and Newport Associates Phase I Developers Limited Partnership is a New Jersey limited partnership. Da53-54, \u00b6\u00b6 9, 10 and 14. Thus, the issues in this coverage action involve commerce. \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 v. BDO \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587, LLP, 393 N.J. Super. 560, 574 (App. Div. 2007) (\u201cA nexus to interstate commerce is found when citizens of different states engage in the performance of contractual obligations in one of those states because such a contract necessitates interstate travel of both personnel and payments.\u201d) Thus, it is indisputable that the FAA governs this matter and \u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587\u2587 did not challenge this point in its opposition papers to ASIC\u2019s motion to compel arbitration.", "snippet_links": [{"key": "subject-to", "type": "definition", "offset": [17, 27]}, {"key": "de-novo-review", "type": "clause", "offset": [28, 42]}, {"key": "valid-and-enforceable", "type": "clause", "offset": [88, 109]}, {"key": "arbitration-agreement", "type": "clause", "offset": [110, 131]}, {"key": "this-court", "type": "definition", "offset": [171, 181]}, {"key": "review-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [185, 194]}, {"key": "an-order", "type": "clause", "offset": [195, 203]}, {"key": "motion-to-compel", "type": "definition", "offset": [214, 230]}, {"key": "arbitration-provision", "type": "clause", "offset": [412, 433]}, {"key": "the-trial", "type": "clause", "offset": [527, 536]}, {"key": "appellate-courts", "type": "definition", "offset": [540, 556]}, {"key": "home-warranty", "type": "definition", "offset": [612, 625]}, {"key": "a-party", "type": "clause", "offset": [776, 783]}, {"key": "trial-court", "type": "definition", "offset": [916, 927]}, {"key": "right-to-arbitrate", "type": "clause", "offset": [1009, 1027]}, {"key": "arbitration-clauses", "type": "clause", "offset": [1041, 1060]}, {"key": "enforcement-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [1142, 1156]}, {"key": "state-courts", "type": "definition", "offset": [1207, 1219]}, {"key": "discover-bank", "type": "definition", "offset": [1290, 1303]}, {"key": "applies-to", "type": "clause", "offset": [1337, 1347]}, {"key": "agreement-to-arbitrate", "type": "definition", "offset": [1436, 1458]}, {"key": "the-united-states", "type": "definition", "offset": [1478, 1495]}, {"key": "supreme-court", "type": "definition", "offset": [1496, 1509]}, {"key": "the-phrase", "type": "definition", "offset": [1524, 1534]}, {"key": "functional-equivalent", "type": "definition", "offset": [1575, 1596]}, {"key": "affecting-commerce", "type": "definition", "offset": [1624, 1642]}, {"key": "exercise-of", "type": "clause", "offset": [1685, 1696]}, {"key": "citizens-bank", "type": "clause", "offset": [1730, 1743]}, {"key": "new-york", "type": "definition", "offset": [1906, 1914]}, {"key": "development-company", "type": "definition", "offset": [1935, 1954]}, {"key": "new-jersey", "type": "definition", "offset": [1960, 1970]}, {"key": "general-partnership", "type": "definition", "offset": [1971, 1990]}, {"key": "phase-i", "type": "clause", "offset": [2014, 2021]}, {"key": "limited-partnership", "type": "clause", "offset": [2033, 2052]}, {"key": "the-issues", "type": "clause", "offset": [2122, 2132]}, {"key": "coverage-action", "type": "definition", "offset": [2141, 2156]}, {"key": "interstate-commerce", "type": "definition", "offset": [2258, 2277]}, {"key": "performance-of-contractual-obligations", "type": "clause", "offset": [2335, 2373]}, {"key": "and-payments", "type": "clause", "offset": [2470, 2482]}], "samples": [{"hash": "1h3VpqfYdEF", "uri": "/contracts/1h3VpqfYdEF#argument", "label": "Insurance Agreement", "score": 34.2154502869, "published": true}], "hash": "46a69a9063ac3135230dde035a354128", "id": 9}, {"size": 1, "snippet": "THE AGREEMENT IS IN THE PUBLIC INTEREST\nA. THE COMMISSION HAS THE AUTHORITY AND COMPETENT SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO APPROVE THE AGREEMENT", "snippet_links": [{"key": "the-agreement", "type": "clause", "offset": [0, 13]}, {"key": "in-the-public-interest", "type": "clause", "offset": [17, 39]}, {"key": "the-commission", "type": "clause", "offset": [43, 57]}, {"key": "authority-and", "type": "clause", "offset": [66, 79]}, {"key": "substantial-evidence", "type": "definition", "offset": [90, 110]}, {"key": "to-approve", "type": "clause", "offset": [111, 121]}], "samples": [{"hash": "61E7QB8DoSk", "uri": "/contracts/61E7QB8DoSk#argument", "label": "Rate Agreement", "score": 29.7734184265, "published": true}], "hash": "244fa467379e8019e6fe6c37f3d0e935", "id": 10}], "next_curs": "ClESS2oVc35sYXdpbnNpZGVyY29udHJhY3Rzci0LEhZDbGF1c2VTbmlwcGV0R3JvdXBfdjU2IhFhcmd1bWVudCMwMDAwMDAwYQyiAQJlbhgAIAA=", "clause": {"parents": [["expedited-arbitration", "Expedited Arbitration"], ["work-of-the-bargaining-unit", "WORK OF THE BARGAINING UNIT"], ["sting-generation-module", "Sting Generation Module"], ["syntactic-information", "Syntactic information"], ["signature", "SIGNATURE"]], "size": 81, "title": "ARGUMENT", "children": [["", ""], ["joint-applicants-mischaracterize-staffs-position", "Joint Applicants mischaracterize Staff\u2019s position"], ["ratepayer-safety", "Ratepayer Safety"], ["nicor-gas-repairs", "Nicor Gas Repairs"], ["delivery-of-a-cheque-for-deposit-does-not-in-law-constitute-a-demand-for-payment-from-the-trust-account-to-the-tax-debtor", "Delivery Of A Cheque For Deposit Does Not, In Law, Constitute A Demand For Payment From The Trust Account To The Tax Debtor"]], "id": "argument", "related": [["forum", "Forum", "Forum"], ["venue", "Venue", "Venue"], ["objections", "Objections", "Objections"], ["hearing", "Hearing", "Hearing"], ["complaint", "Complaint", "Complaint"]], "related_snippets": [], "updated": "2025-07-23T06:00:56+00:00"}, "json": true, "cursor": ""}}